Rybbit vs Umami (2026)
Head-to-head comparison for vibe coders: scores, free tiers, pricing and best-for, using the same evidence-based methodology. Rankings are never for sale.
Open-source, cookieless Google Analytics replacement with session replay and funnels
Open-source, cookieless web analytics with a real free cloud tier
Side-by-side comparison
| Criterion | Rybbit | Umami |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 77/100 | 84/100 |
| Free tier | No free cloud plan (7-day free trial); self-hosting is free under AGPL-3.0 | Yes: Umami Cloud Hobby is free forever for 100K events/mo on 1 website with 6-month retention; self-hosting the MIT-licensed app is free |
| Open source | Yes | Yes |
| Pricing | Cloud by monthly pageviews (100K to 20M+): Standard from $13/mo billed annually (up to 5 websites, 3 team members, 3-year retention); Pro from $26/mo billed annually (unlimited sites and members, session replays, 5-year retention, priority support); Enterprise custom. Annual billing = 4 months free; 7-day free trial. Self-host free (AGPL-3.0) | Cloud: Hobby $0 (100K events/mo, 1 website, 6-month retention); Pro $20/mo (1M events, then $0.00003/event, up to 20 websites, 10 members, 2-year retention, API + MCP access); Business $200/mo (10M events, unlimited sites, 5-year retention, 5,000 session replays, heatmaps); Enterprise custom. Self-host free (MIT) |
| Best for | Sites and vibe-coded apps that want GA-level insight (replays, funnels, vitals) with no cookie banner | Indie sites and vibe-coded SaaS that want free, GDPR-friendly web analytics they can self-host later |
| Category | Analytics & monitoring | Analytics & monitoring |
Score breakdown
| Criterion | Rybbit | Umami |
|---|---|---|
| Fit for the use case /25 | 20 | 21 |
| Vibe-coder friendliness /15 | 12 | 13 |
| Output quality & reliability /15 | 11 | 12 |
| Pricing & free tier /15 | 10 | 13 |
| Ecosystem & integrations /10 | 6 | 7 |
| Momentum /10 | 8 | 8 |
| Code ownership & lock-in /10 | 10 | 10 |
Based on desk research of official pricing pages and docs; see methodology.
How they differ
Both are open-source, cookieless web analytics you can run in their cloud or self-host. Umami (84) is MIT-licensed with about 39.4k GitHub stars and the only one of the two with a free cloud plan. Rybbit (77) is AGPL-3.0 with about 13.1k stars and bundles funnels, journeys, retention, web vitals, error tracking and user profiles on its entry plan, with session replay on Pro.
What you pay
Umami Cloud: Hobby $0 (100K events/mo, 1 website, 6-month retention); Pro $20/mo (1M events, then $0.00003 per event, up to 20 websites, 10 members, 2-year retention, API and MCP access); Business $200/mo (10M events, unlimited sites, 5-year retention, 5,000 session replays, heatmaps). Rybbit: Standard from $13/mo billed annually (100K pageviews, up to 5 sites, 3-year retention) and Pro from $26/mo billed annually (unlimited sites, session replays, 5-year retention), after a 7-day trial. Note the units: Umami counts events, Rybbit counts pageviews.
Which to pick
Umami to start free on one site, or if you want the permissive MIT license. Rybbit if you want session replays and error tracking in a privacy-first tool for far less than Umami Business.
Who wins: Rybbit or Umami?
By score, Umami wins Rybbit vs Umami at 84/100 vs 77/100. Umami: The best free privacy-first web analytics: a forever-free cloud tier (100K events) plus MIT self-hosting, cookieless, and an MCP for agents on Pro. Narrower than PostHog (no flags or experiments; replays only on Business), but beats Plausible on free tier and license. Rybbit: A fast-growing open-source analytics project (~13k GitHub stars, pushed Oct 16 2026, v2.9.0) that bundles replays, funnels, journeys, web vitals and error tracking behind one cookieless script, plus an MCP server. No free cloud tier and session replay only on Pro cost pricing points; it is newer than Plausible or Umami. Umami is best for Indie sites and vibe-coded SaaS that want free, GDPR-friendly web analytics they can self-host later. Rybbit is best for Sites and vibe-coded apps that want GA-level insight (replays, funnels, vitals) with no cookie banner.
FAQ
- Which is better, Rybbit or Umami?
- By our score, Umami (84/100) ranks above Rybbit (77/100). Umami is best for Indie sites and vibe-coded SaaS that want free, GDPR-friendly web analytics they can self-host later. The right pick still depends on your workflow; see the side-by-side table.
- What is the Rybbit vs Umami score?
- Rybbit scores 77/100 and Umami scores 84/100 on PromptToProd's evidence-based ranking. Scores are never for sale.
- Which is cheaper if I want session replay?
- Rybbit. Pro, from $26/mo billed annually, includes session replays. On Umami Cloud, replays start with the Business plan at $200/mo (5,000 included).
- Is Umami free?
- Yes. Umami Cloud Hobby is free for 100K events a month on 1 website with 6-month retention, and the MIT-licensed app is free to self-host.